Scam watch · 9 Nov 2026

Is Affiliate Marketing a Scam? Real Programs vs Schemes

Real affiliate programs are free to join; the schemes the FTC shut down charged first. A dated red-flag table, the US and UK rules and a 6-step check.

Greg Ciupek 10 min read 20 sources Comment
Cover: is affiliate marketing a scam, real programs such as Amazon Associates, Shopify and eBay Partner Network cost $0 to join, while schemes shut down by the FTC charged fees first
Short answer · as of 7 Nov 2026
  • No. Affiliate marketing is a legal advertising model; the scams are schemes that borrow the word "affiliate".
  • The clearest test is money flowing the wrong way. Amazon Associates, the Shopify Affiliate Program and eBay Partner Network are all free to join, with a $10 minimum payout (terms checked 7 Nov 2026).
  • The schemes the FTC shut down charged first: $27 plus $100 or more in setup at The Online Entrepreneur (FTC, 20 Mar 2014), $49 and then memberships of thousands of dollars at MOBE (FTC, 11 Jun 2018).
  • Even honest dashboards lie by default: on my affiliate blog a network recorded 153 partner-link clicks with about 1 real reader behind them.
Contents · 8 sections
  1. 01Is affiliate marketing a scam, or a legal business model?
  2. 02Is affiliate marketing a scam? Real program terms vs schemes, side by side
  3. 03Is affiliate marketing a scam when the clicks are fake? Our numbers
  4. 04Is affiliate marketing a scam under US and UK law?
  5. 05How to check if an affiliate program is a scam: six steps
  6. 06Is affiliate marketing a scam if you have to recruit people?
  7. 07Frequently asked questions
  8. 08Sources

This is for you if someone has pitched you an "affiliate program", a course or a "system" and you are trying to work out whether it is the real thing or a trap. I will not tell you what you can earn; I will show you what real programs put in writing and what the schemes did, according to US and UK regulators.

All sources were read on 7 Nov 2026. I name companies, not people. This is not legal advice.

Is affiliate marketing a scam? No: it is a legal form of performance-based advertising, which the UK's ASA describes as a business rewarding an affiliate for each new customer their marketing brings in (AdviceOnline, 22 Mar 2023). Scams appear when a seller charges you to join, pays you for recruiting, or promises income it cannot back up.

The word "affiliate" is also used for things that are not affiliate marketing at all. Vemma, a multilevel marketing company, called its members "affiliates" while, according to the FTC, it focused on recruitment rather than retail sales (FTC, 26 Aug 2015). The label tells you nothing; the terms do.

Is affiliate marketing a scam? Real program terms vs schemes, side by side

Real affiliate programs and affiliate-themed schemes differ on seven checkable points, from who pays whom on day one to whether income claims come with evidence. Each red flag below is tied to a dated FTC action and the rule it touches.

Legit affiliate program vs scheme: official program terms and FTC/ASA primary sources, as of 7 Nov 2026
CheckReal program (official terms)Scheme (regulator, date)Rule it touches
Who pays on day oneAmazon Associates: free to join (Program Policies, updated 14 Apr 2026). Shopify Affiliate Program and eBay Partner Network: free to join (their official pages)The Online Entrepreneur: a $27 fee, then $100 or more just to set up the website (FTC, 20 Mar 2014). MOBE: $49 entry, then memberships costing thousands (FTC, 11 Jun 2018)16 CFR 437.1: a "required payment" is one of the three elements of a business opportunity
What you are paid forAmazon: qualifying purchases by customers who click your link (Operating Agreement, updated 15 Oct 2025)MOBE's "proven system" turned out to be selling the same memberships to others (FTC, 11 Jun 2018). Vemma's order: no pay unless most of an affiliate's revenue comes from real customers (FTC, 15 Dec 2016)CAP Code rule 3.16 bans promoting pyramid schemes (ASA, 5 Jun 2025)
Paid "help" to get startedAmazon says it has never authorized any business to sell paid set-up or consulting services to associates (Program Policies, 14 Apr 2026)MOBE affiliates drew people into "mentoring" costing as much as $60,000 (FTC, 5 Mar 2020)Unsubstantiated earnings claims; FTC Act Section 5
Income claimsNone of the three program pages I read promises what you will earn; they describe how and when commissions are paidVemma claimed affiliates could earn as much as $50,000 per week (FTC, 26 Aug 2015); Vemma's judgment was $238 million, partly suspended (FTC, 15 Dec 2016)16 CFR 437.4: a written "earnings claim statement" with how many buyers reached the figure
TestimonialsAmazon requires the plain line "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases."An Automators AI affiliate posted sales and profit numbers the operators knew were false; his store was losing money (FTC, 22 Aug 2023)16 CFR 255.2(b): a testimonial is read as typical unless expected results are disclosed
Refunds and "no risk"No program fee, so nothing to refund; payout minimum $10 at all three (Amazon $100 by check, with a $15 fee)MOBE's money-back guarantees were often refused (FTC, 11 Jun 2018); The Online Entrepreneur sold a "no-risk" offer (FTC, 20 Mar 2014)16 CFR 437.3: refund terms belong in the disclosure document
Lifestyle marketingProgram pages show tools, payout methods and rulesVemma showed young people with luxury cars, jets and yachts (FTC, 26 Aug 2015)ASA/CAP: affiliate ads must be obviously identifiable and not misleading (rules 2.1, 2.3)

Program terms read on 7 Nov 2026; eBay's $10 threshold is on an undated partner-network page.

Watch out

Vemma was a multilevel marketing company and is here only as a warning. This site never recommends MLM or "network" programs. If an "affiliate pack" costs money and you must keep buying products to stay eligible (at Vemma, $150 a month, FTC 2015), walk away.

Is affiliate marketing a scam when the clicks are fake? Our numbers

Affiliate clicks are not people. On madrydochod.pl, my Polish affiliate blog launched on 6 Oct 2026, a partner network recorded 153 partner-link clicks while about 1 real reader was behind them; the rest were bots. That gap is why I built my own /go/ counter, which only counts humans.

153partner-link clicks recorded by the network
about 1real reader behind them
$0to join Amazon, Shopify or eBay programs (7 Nov 2026)
Our numbers

madrydochod.pl and its partners are Polish, so this is a lab, not an option for US or UK readers. The lesson travels: a network dashboard counts link requests, and bots make plenty of them.

So a screenshot of a dashboard full of clicks proves nothing about readers, and schemes love screenshots. Judge any program by human clicks and confirmed sales. The full click-to-payout path is in What is affiliate marketing?, and live human traffic for my fleet is on the Empire Counter.

Is affiliate marketing a scam under US and UK law?

Under US and UK law affiliate marketing is legal, but both countries hold the affiliate personally responsible. The FTC said on 5 Mar 2020 that it will hold affiliates accountable for false or unsubstantiated claims, and the ASA says both the business and the affiliate are responsible under the CAP Code (AdviceOnline, 22 Mar 2023).

United States: FTC

  • Business Opportunity Rule (16 CFR 437). A business opportunity needs a required payment plus a promise of locations, outlets, accounts or customers, including internet outlets. If it applies, you must get a disclosure document at least seven calendar days before you sign or pay (16 CFR 437.2). A free program with no required payment does not meet the definition. On eCFR (up to date 5 Nov 2026) I found no final rule extending it to business coaching, which the FTC proposed on 13 Jan 2025.
  • Endorsement Guides (16 CFR 255), revised 29 Jun 2023. Section 255.5 says a material connection, such as payment, must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously; one of its examples is a blog with affiliate links. The 2023 revision added that a platform's built-in disclosure tool might not be enough.
  • Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers (FTC, November 2019). The disclosure goes with the endorsement, not only on a profile page; avoid vague tags like "sp".

United Kingdom: ASA/CAP and CMA

  • ASA/CAP. Rule 2.1 requires that marketing is obviously identifiable; on blogs and social media an affiliate link usually needs an extra label (AdviceOnline "Affiliate marketing", 22 Mar 2023). Rule 3.16 bans promoting pyramid schemes (AdviceOnline "Pyramid schemes", 5 Jun 2025).
  • CMA. Its guidance for content creators (updated 3 Sep 2025) lists "affiliated links or programmes" among the things that must be labelled as an ad.
Not legal advice

I am not a lawyer; I summarize what the regulators published. If you have paid a scheme, report it at reportfraud.ftc.gov (US) or to Action Fraud (UK).

How to check if an affiliate program is a scam: six steps

To check if an affiliate program is a scam, find its official terms page, confirm it costs nothing to join, confirm you are paid for sales to real customers, and look the seller up on ftc.gov and asa.org.uk. A real program passes all six steps.

  1. Find the written terms. A real program has an operating agreement or terms page on the brand's own domain, with a date. No terms, no deal.
  2. Follow the money on day one. If you must pay to join, buy a "starter pack" or pay for mandatory coaching before you can earn, treat it as a business opportunity sale, not an affiliate program. Ask for the FTC disclosure document.
  3. Ask what triggers a payment. The answer should be a purchase or sign-up by a customer. If it is "bringing in new members", you are looking at a recruitment model.
  4. Ask for the earnings claim statement. Under 16 CFR 437.4 an earnings claim must come with the number and percentage of earlier buyers who reached it.
  5. Search the regulators. Search the company and its "system" names on ftc.gov and asa.org.uk. MOBE affiliates sold under their own brand names, such as "Rookie Profit System" (FTC, 5 Mar 2020), so search those too.
  6. Check payout terms. Look for a stated minimum and schedule: $10 at all three programs above, and about 60 days after month end at Amazon.

Honest early results, hours against payouts, are in Is affiliate marketing worth it? My dated list of 12 FTC and ASA actions against course sellers is in Make money online scams.

Is affiliate marketing a scam if you have to recruit people?

If a program pays you mainly for recruiting other members rather than for sales to outside customers, it is not affiliate marketing in the normal sense. In the Vemma settlement (FTC, 15 Dec 2016), pay was banned unless most of an affiliate's revenue came from sales to real customers.

Normal affiliate programs have no "downline". Your income depends on customers buying the brand's product. MOBE inverted this: according to the FTC, people paid for memberships and were then told to sell the same memberships to others (11 Jun 2018). The FTC later returned more than $23 million to over 37,000 consumers (FTC, 5 Apr 2022).

Frequently asked questions

Is affiliate marketing a scam or legit?

Affiliate marketing is a legitimate, legal advertising model used by brands such as Amazon, Shopify and eBay, whose programs were free to join when I checked on 7 Nov 2026. The scams are schemes that charge you to join or pay you for recruiting.

Do you have to pay to join an affiliate program?

No, not for the large programs. Amazon's Program Policies (updated 14 Apr 2026) state that the Associates Program is free to join, and Shopify and eBay say the same. A program that asks for money before you can earn is a red flag.

Can an affiliate get in trouble for a scheme they promoted?

Yes. In March 2020 the FTC settled with MOBE affiliates who made false earnings claims; one order carried a $31.6 million judgment, suspended after a $760,000 payment, and all were banned from selling business coaching (FTC, 5 Mar 2020). In the UK, the ASA holds both the brand and the affiliate responsible.

What is the minimum payout at real affiliate programs?

At Amazon Associates US it is $10 by direct deposit or gift card and $100 by check, with a $15 check fee. Shopify requires a $10 balance and eBay Partner Network lists a $10 threshold (all checked 7 Nov 2026).

More on the money side of affiliate work is in the Affiliate marketing topic.

Sources

  1. FTC, press release on The Online Entrepreneur settlement (20 Mar 2014): ftc.gov
  2. FTC, press release halting MOBE (11 Jun 2018): ftc.gov
  3. FTC, press release on the MOBE affiliates settlement (5 Mar 2020): ftc.gov
  4. FTC, press release on MOBE refunds (5 Apr 2022): ftc.gov
  5. FTC, press release halting Vemma (26 Aug 2015): ftc.gov
  6. FTC, press release on the Vemma settlement (15 Dec 2016): ftc.gov
  7. FTC, press release halting Automators AI (22 Aug 2023): ftc.gov
  8. FTC, press release proposing Business Opportunity Rule changes (13 Jan 2025): ftc.gov
  9. eCFR, 16 CFR Part 437, Business Opportunity Rule (read 7 Nov 2026, up to date as of 5 Nov 2026): ecfr.gov
  10. eCFR, 16 CFR Part 255, Endorsement Guides (revision of 26 Jul 2023, read 7 Nov 2026): ecfr.gov
  11. FTC, press release on the updated Endorsement Guides (29 Jun 2023): ftc.gov
  12. FTC, "Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers" (November 2019): ftc.gov
  13. ASA/CAP, AdviceOnline "Affiliate marketing" (22 Mar 2023): asa.org.uk
  14. ASA/CAP, AdviceOnline "Pyramid schemes" (5 Jun 2025): asa.org.uk
  15. CMA, "Social media endorsements: guidance for content creators" (updated 3 Sep 2025): gov.uk
  16. Amazon, Associates Program Operating Agreement (updated 15 Oct 2025, read 7 Nov 2026): affiliate-program.amazon.com
  17. Amazon, Associates Program Policies, incl. Payment Minimum Chart (updated 14 Apr 2026, read 7 Nov 2026): affiliate-program.amazon.com
  18. Shopify, Shopify Affiliate Program FAQ (read 7 Nov 2026): shopify.com
  19. eBay, "eBay Partner Network" help page (read 7 Nov 2026): ebay.com
  20. eBay Partner Network, "Our partnership" (undated, read 7 Nov 2026): partnernetwork.ebay.com

As of 7 Nov 2026. I read the FTC press releases, 16 CFR 437 and 255 on eCFR, the ASA/CAP and CMA guidance, and the Amazon, Shopify and eBay program pages on 7 Nov 2026. The 153 clicks and about 1 real reader come from our fleet fact register for madrydochod.pl (its first weeks after the 6 Oct 2026 launch). Program terms change; check the official page before you sign up.

Read next

Discussion

Comments and questions

Got a question about this piece, or numbers of your own to share? Write it here. I answer in the comments, and the answer stays here for the next reader.

    No comments yet. Have a question or your own experience to share? Go first: your question will help other readers too.

    Add a comment

    No referral links. We don't publish referral codes or affiliate links. Comments with them wait for a moderator, and the link gets removed. Discussion rules

    Why?

    Under posts about affiliate marketing, everyone would like to drop their own link, and real questions would drown in ads. We also don't want to pick whose link is "better". On top of that, the terms of many partner programs and affiliate networks forbid posting links in other people's comment sections. Break that rule and a network can close your account, commissions included.

    Report a comment

    Reason

    Free Starter Kit · PDF

    Avoid online income scams. Build something boring and legal.

    Free · the kit now, 6 short e-mails over 11 days, then weekly · one-click unsubscribe

    What are you interested in?

    You confirm with a link in your inbox, the kit comes straight after. Then The Empire Report once a week; unsubscribe with one click.