
- I mapped 10 red flags of online business gurus to the US and UK rule or enforcement action behind each, from primary sources checked on 14 Nov 2026.
- The newest case is a student-income claim: Publishing.com agreed to pay $1.5 million (FTC, 13 Apr 2026) over "$1k to $3k a month" that most buyers never reached, per the FTC.
- Watch the upsell ladder: Lurn sold courses, then pitched "coaching" costing up to $10,000 (FTC, 28 Sep 2023).
- Most courses fall outside the US Business Opportunity Rule, so the seller owes you no disclosure document. The FTC proposed changing that on 13 Jan 2025; on 14 Nov 2026 it was still a proposal.
- For contrast, my own e-book from 2015 made about $500 a month for 2 years and then stopped, and my newest blog's first conversion (23 Oct 2026) pays about $75 only if the account stays open 30 days.
Contents · 7 sections
- 01Online business guru red flags: which ones have regulators actually acted on?
- 02Online business guru red flags in income claims: what does the law say?
- 03Online business guru red flags on social media: how do you spot a hidden ad or affiliate?
- 04Online business guru red flags vs honest numbers: what does a real info-product earn?
- 05Online business guru red flags checklist: how do I check a course before I pay?
- 06Frequently asked questions
- 07Sources
This is for you if a coach, mentor or "online business guru" is pitching a course or a mastermind and you want to know which tactics regulators have already called deceptive. I map tactics to rules and published cases, not to names.
For AI-run stores and "done for you" packages, see make money online scams. This article is narrower: the person selling the knowledge. It is not legal advice.
Online business guru red flags: which ones have regulators actually acted on?
Online business guru red flags that regulators have acted on fall into ten repeat tactics, from income screenshots and incentivized testimonials to unlabeled affiliate promoters and fake deadlines. Each row below links one tactic to a US rule or FTC case and a UK CAP Code rule or ASA position, checked on 14 Nov 2026.
| Red flag (what you see) | US: rule or FTC action | UK: rule or ASA/CMA position |
|---|---|---|
| 1. "My students make $X a month" | Publishing.com: $1.5 million, earnings claims must be substantiated (FTC, 13 Apr 2026); 16 CFR 255.2(b) | CAP Code 3.1 and 3.7 (evidence before publishing) |
| 2. "Results not typical" in small print | 16 CFR 255.2(b): the disclosure must change the net impression of the ad | CAP Code 3.9: qualifications must not contradict the claim (ASA, 9 Apr 2026) |
| 3. Reviews and "case studies" that pay the reviewer | Publishing.com: prizes, cash and refunds offered for positive testimonials, per the complaint; 16 CFR 465.4 (since 21 Oct 2024) | CAP Code 3.44 (fake reviews) and 3.45 (incentivised reviews) |
| 4. A "review" video by someone earning commission | MOBE affiliates: permanent bans, one order of $3.35 million paid in full (FTC, 5 Mar 2020); 16 CFR 255.5 | CAP Code 2.1 and 2.3; "*affiliate" alone was not enough (Asos ruling, 22 Apr 2020) |
| 5. Complaints vanish online | Response Marketing Group: $15 million settlement plus $1.7 million from two endorsers; over $10 million refunded (FTC, 21 Mar 2024); 16 CFR 255.2(d) | CAP Code 3.46: removing negative reviews is misleading |
| 6. A contract that bars reviews | Zurixx: order bans review-gagging terms; over $12 million refunded to 25,563 people (FTC, 31 Jul 2024) | CAP Code 3.46 |
| 7. Cheap course, then a $10,000 "coaching" pitch | Lurn, which kept going after the 2021 Notice: $14,077,121 judgment, partly suspended, $2.5 million to turn over (FTC, 28 Sep 2023) | CAP Code 3.1; ASA project on money-making courses (9 Apr 2026) |
| 8. "No questions asked" refund with conditions | Publishing.com: order requires refund terms to be disclosed and honored (FTC, 13 Apr 2026) | CAP Code 3.9 and 3.10 (qualifications must be clear) |
| 9. "Doors close tonight", a "free" webinar that is a sales pitch | Notice of Penalty Offenses on money-making claims, including false "act immediately" (FTC, 26 Oct 2021) | CAP Code 3.30 (false limited time) and 3.23 ("free") |
| 10. "No experience needed", "I'm 100% confident we can help you" | Same 2021 Notice; Lurn's sales script used that exact sentence, per the FTC | CAP Code 3.11 (exaggerating what a product can do) |
Amounts are as published by the FTC. The ASA does not fine; the ad must not appear again.
Online business guru red flags in income claims: what does the law say?
Online business guru red flags around income are judged by one test in both countries: is the result shown what a typical buyer gets? In the US, 16 CFR 255.2(b) treats a testimonial as typical unless the ad clearly discloses generally expected results. In the UK, CAP Code rule 3.7 requires evidence before the ad runs.
United States
The FTC's Endorsement Guides (16 CFR 255, last amended 26 Jul 2023, per eCFR) say a disclosure of expected results "must alter the net impression" of the ad. A tiny "results not typical" line under a screenshot of a record month does not do that.
Not every seller must hand you an earnings claim statement. That applies to a "business opportunity" under 16 CFR 437, where the seller promises locations, outlets, accounts or customers, or to buy back what you make. A video course usually promises none of those. The FTC's 13 Jan 2025 proposal would extend the rule to business coaching; on 14 Nov 2026 the eCFR text of part 437 had changed only in its appendix forms (12 Feb 2026), not in scope.
Course claims are still covered by the FTC Act's ban on deception, which is how Lurn and Publishing.com were charged.
United Kingdom
On 9 Apr 2026 the ASA summed up its project on money-making courses: inflated income claims, testimonials that suggest exceptional results are normal, "free" offers that are not free, and deadlines that are not real. It said disclaimers failed because they "contradicted rather than clarified" the headline claim. Under the DMCC Act 2024, in force since April 2025, the CMA can fine a company up to 10% of global turnover (CMA, 7 Apr 2025).
"I can't share income numbers, but…" followed by a lifestyle reel can still suggest what you will earn. The FTC's 2021 Notice lists representing that profits are typical as unlawful, and the ASA's 2026 project covered "dramatic lifestyle upgrades" as well as revenue figures.
Online business guru red flags on social media: how do you spot a hidden ad or affiliate?
Online business guru red flags on social media start with missing labels. The FTC's "Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers" (November 2019) says a paid relationship must be disclosed with the endorsement itself, and the ASA expects a clear "Ad" label upfront (guidance updated 6 Aug 2026). A bio-only disclosure fails both tests.
Many "honest review" videos of a course earn commission on each sale. In the FTC's MOBE case, affiliate marketers who promoted a coaching program costing up to $60,000 were permanently banned from selling business coaching, and the FTC said it would hold affiliates "personally and financially accountable" (5 Mar 2020).
- US. Disclosures 101 says not to rely on vague tags such as "sp", "spon" or "collab", and not to hide a disclosure among hashtags or behind "more". 16 CFR 255.5 covers money, free products and family or business ties.
- UK. The ASA's affiliate guidance (22 Mar 2023) records that a standalone "*affiliate" label was not enough. The CMA's guide for content creators (updated 3 Sep 2025) says it is "not enough" to tag a brand or use discount codes or affiliate links,, including posts about your own business.
What a correct disclosure looks like on a blog is in affiliate disclosure examples. Whether affiliate marketing itself is legitimate is covered in is affiliate marketing a scam.
Online business guru red flags vs honest numbers: what does a real info-product earn?
Online business guru red flags are easier to spot next to real numbers. My own Polish e-book from 2015, 54 pages written in 7 days and priced at about $9–$18, brought in about $500 a month for 2 years. Sales died when I dropped info-products and my personal brand.
That is the part gurus leave out: the income depended on me staying visible, not on a system. If a guru's main income is selling the course, the course proves they can sell courses, not that the method works for you.
Audience is not proof: my Instagram account had 11,200 followers on 20 Oct 2026, with an average of 6.7 likes per post and 71 of the last 96 posts without a comment, an engagement rate of 0.07%. My newest affiliate blog, madrydochod.pl, had 80 people in 9 days from server logs (17–25 Oct 2026); its first conversion on 23 Oct 2026 pays about $75 only if the account stays open 30 days.
No course would sell with those numbers on the sales page. Early results are small, uneven and slow; if a pitch shows only the best outcomes, ask what everyone else got. I explain why I publish the weak numbers in the manifesto.
Online business guru red flags checklist: how do I check a course before I pay?
To check an online business guru before you pay, ask in writing what share of buyers reached the advertised result, search the company and its trading names on ftc.gov and asa.org.uk, read the refund terms in full and check every reviewer for an affiliate link. Each step below rests on a rule or case checked on 14 Nov 2026.
- Ask for typical results. Email: "How many buyers since launch, and how many reached the income in your ads?" A seller with real data can answer.
- Search every name. Look up the company, its program names and the founder's business name on ftc.gov (Cases and Proceedings) and asa.org.uk (Rulings).
- Check the reviewers. Open three "reviews" of the course. If the link carries a code or tracking parameter and there is no upfront "Ad" label, treat it as an ad.
- Read the refund policy before the sales call. Save a copy. "No questions asked" followed by conditions is exactly what the FTC challenged at Publishing.com.
- Test the deadline. Reload the page in another browser or come back the next day. CAP Code 3.30 bans falsely saying an offer is available only for a limited time.
- Price the whole ladder. Ask what the next tier costs before buying the first one. Lurn's upsells reached $10,000.
If you already paid, report it: in the US at reportfraud.ftc.gov, in the UK to the ASA (misleading ads) or to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk, and contact your card issuer. More cases like these are collected under Reports.
Frequently asked questions
Are all online business gurus scams?
No. The regulators acted on specific tactics: unproven income claims, incentivized or hidden testimonials, buried complaints, refund conditions and fake deadlines. A teacher who shows typical results, costs and failures is doing something different. Run the checklist above either way.
Does "results not typical" make an income screenshot legal?
Not on its own. Under 16 CFR 255.2(b) the disclosure must change the net impression of the ad, and the ASA said on 9 Apr 2026 that disclaimers contradicting a headline claim do not save it. A screenshot with small print is still a red flag.
Can I get my money back after an FTC case?
Sometimes, partly. The FTC sent over $2.4 million to 1,922 Lurn buyers (6 Jun 2024) and over $12 million to 25,563 Zurixx buyers (31 Jul 2024). Refunds come from what defendants pay, so they rarely cover everything. The FTC says it never charges for a refund.
Sources
- FTC press releases: Publishing.com (13 Apr 2026), Lurn (28 Sep 2023), Lurn refunds (6 Jun 2024), MOBE affiliates (5 Mar 2020), Response Marketing Group refunds (21 Mar 2024), Zurixx refunds (31 Jul 2024), Notice on money-making claims (26 Oct 2021), Notice on endorsements (13 Oct 2021), proposed Business Opportunity Rule changes (13 Jan 2025)
- FTC, Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers (November 2019, checked 14 Nov 2026): ftc.gov
- eCFR, 16 CFR 255, 437 and 465 (read 14 Nov 2026)
- ASA, Money making courses: stick to the facts (9 Apr 2026): asa.org.uk
- CAP, Online affiliate marketing (22 Mar 2023): asa.org.uk
- CAP, Recognising ads: social media and influencer marketing (6 Aug 2026): asa.org.uk
- CAP Code, sections 2 and 3 (read 14 Nov 2026): asa.org.uk, asa.org.uk
- CMA, Social media endorsements: guidance for content creators (updated 3 Sep 2025): gov.uk
- CMA, new consumer protection regime comes into force (7 Apr 2025): gov.uk
- Greg Ciupek, "The Weight of Winning" (2026) for the 2015 e-book; Instagram account statistics (20 Oct 2026); madrydochod.pl server logs and partner program report (Oct 2026); all from our fact register.
As of 14 Nov 2026. I read every source on 14 Nov 2026 (FTC releases on the FTC's own search.ftc.gov host, because ftc.gov blocks automated requests). I name companies, not people. The e-book price, its monthly income and the madrydochod.pl payout were converted to US dollars at the October 2026 rate (about 4.0 to the dollar). New FTC and ASA actions will be added as they are published.



